Contact Us

    Please use the contact form to send us an email - and receive a response within 12 hours.

    Emergency? Call 720-220-2277 (24/7)

    Please leave this field empty.

Map To Our Office
Read Out Blog
Case Evaluation
Charged With A Crime?

Apr 22

Colorado Social Services Records and Sex Crimes Defense Law

By Colorado Sex Crimes Defense Lawyer – H. Michael Steinberg

Colorado Social Services Records and Sex Crimes Defense Law – In a recent 2013 case handed down from the Colorado Court of Appeals – a Sexual Assault case was reversed because of a failure of the judge to permit the parties to access social service records pertaining to the prior alleged abuse of the victims in the case.

Colorado Social Services Records and Sex Crimes Defense Law

Colorado Social Services Records and Sex Crimes Defense Law

The case is important because it addresses the issue of access to otherwise confidential records that could assist in the defense of Colorado sex crimes charges that mandate indeterminate life sentences.

The Facts:

The Defendant, Theodore Herrera, appealed the lower court conviction for two counts of sexual assault on a child and two counts of sexual assault-pattern of abuse.

Colorado’s Rape Shield Law

Aware of the existence of social service records that might form the basis for a defense – and prior to the trial, the defense filed a motion under the rape shield statute, section 18-3-407, C.R.S

The analysis of this case is important as it gives guidance to Colorado criminal defense lawyers on the obligations of the prosecution to disclose evidence that points to the innocence of the accused in a Colorado sex crime case.

The rape shield motion requested leave of the Court to admit evidence of the victim’s prior allegations of sexual assault. The trial court ordered the DA to disclose any information regarding known, false allegations of or investigations concerning sexual assault of the victim.

The prosecutor had information that the alleged victim had made prior allegations of sexual assault which were likely reported in her social services records. 

The prosecutor obtained the records and gave them to the judge – asking the judge to determine which records should be released to the defense – per the standard procedures and protocols in this areas. The judge’s review of the records is called an “in camera” review.

The judge refused to perform the review!

Colorado Law On The Camera Review of Social Services Records

On appeal after the lower court’s decision – the Colorado Court of Appeals held that the trial court abused its discretion by:

“…. denying the requests made by both him and the People to conduct an in camera review of the social services records to determine whether they contained information material to his case that should have been disclosed prior to trial.

..The … requisite threshold showing that in camera review of the records was necessary and (the defendant) joined in this request, we conclude that the trial court abused its discretion, and we remand the case for in camera review of the records.”

Here’s Why.. The Confidentiality of Minor’s Records In Colorado

Colorado Law 19-1-307, C.R.S. requires that minors’ abuse and neglect social services records remain confidential, subject to several exceptions.

Three of those exceptions applied here:

Section 19-1-307(2)(a), grants certain government agents, including prosecutors, open access to these records.  BUT members of the public, including defendants in criminal cases, generally have no right of access to such records. Rather, a defendant only may access information contained in the records that a court has decided “is necessary for the resolution of an issue then pending before [the court].” § 19-1-307(2)(f) C.R.S. 2011.

Even the Courts themselves are limited to accessing social services records “upon . . . finding that access to such records may be necessary for determination of an issue before [it],” and even then, only by means of an in camera review.

Colorado Social Services Records and Sex Crimes Defense Law – The Two Part Test For Access to Colorado Social Services Records

The disclosure to a defendant of information contained in confidential social services records requires a two-part inquiry by the judge:

(1) The Judge must make a threshold determination whether to conduct an in camera review. Because a court may violate a defendant’s due process rights by failing to conduct an in camera review of potentially material information, it “should approach this threshold inquiry liberally and conduct [such a] review whenever it reasonably appears that the records may contain discoverable information.”

(2) If a court decides to undertake an in camera review, it must then determine what discoverable information in the records, if any, must be disclosed to the defendant.

Either side may request court-ordered disclosure of social services records. The procedures by which each may request disclosure differ.

The Brady Rule of Pretrial Discovery

A prosecutor is legally and ethically obligated to disclose to a criminal defendant evidence or information of which he or she learns that is favorable to the defendant and material to either guilt or punishment, including exculpatory and impeaching evidence. Brady v. Maryland,

But a different law – Colorado section 19-1- 307 prohibits a prosecutor from disclosing to the defendant such information if it is contained in confidential dependency and neglect records.

The Resolution Of This Conflict

To protect the rights of a defendant without violating confidentiality issues surrounding the records, the lower court MUST REVIEW “any records that contain evidence a prosecutor reasonably believes to be exculpatory or impeaching.”

The trial court should also review records believed to contain inculpatory information that would materially assist a defendant in preparing a defense.

Tougher Road For A Defendant Who Requests A Social Services Records Review

A criminal defendant lacks access by right to these confidential records. The defendant has a tough  row to hoe to compel the review of these records.

Here is the TEST:

A defendant must identify relevant dependency and neglect records and request the trial court to review them in camera based upon his or her belief that information contained therein is necessary for determination of any issue pending before the court. § 19-1-307(2)(f).

The request cannot a “mere fishing expedition.”  The defendant must identify the type of information sought, and make an offer of proof establishing “an evidentiary hypothesis as to how the requested information would be relevant to the . . . case generic tadalafil.”

A trial judge is in error if the court refuses to review social service records after the prosecution  requested an in camera review based upon their belief that the records contained exculpatory, impeaching, and inculpatory information.

This case established a new rule that the defense can rely on and join a prosecutor’s request for in camera review of confidential social services records, and specifically on the prosecutor’s statement that there is information contained in those records that would be ” material to the defense.”

Therefore – when a prosecutor has requested the court’s in camera review of confidential social services records based on a reasonable belief that ..

they contain exculpatory, impeaching, or inculpatory information that would materially assist in preparing the defense, the defendant has no additional burden to make a separate request – and the defendant’s burden to show necessity  is relieved.

Denver Colorado Criminal Defense Lawyer

The Law Offices of H. Michael Steinberg, in Denver, Colorado, provides criminal defense clients with effective, efficient, intelligent and strong legal advocacy. We can educate you and help you navigate the stressful and complex legal process related to your criminal defense issue.

H. Michael Steinberg, is a Denver, Colorado criminal defense lawyer who will provide you with a free initial case consultation to evaluate your legal issues and answer your questions with an honest assessment of your options.

Colorado Social Services Records and Sex Crimes Defense Law

tags: Keywords: Discovery Violation by Prosecutor in Colorado, Sex Crimes, Social Services Records secrecy, Colorado’s Rape Shield Law, Herrera case, Colorado Social Services Records and Sex Crimes Defense Law,

viagra cymbalta viagra prednisone prednisone cymbalta viagra viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra viagra prednisone viagra cymbalta viagra cymbalta viagra viagra cymbalta viagra keflex prednisone viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra prednisone viagra prednisone prednisone viagra viagra viagra viagra cymbalta prednisone cymbalta prednisone viagra prednisone viagra viagra viagra prednisone keflex viagra prednisone cymbalta cymbalta keflex levitra viagra cymbalta viagra prednisone viagra prednisone viagra levitra prednisone prednisone keflex prednisone cymbalta cymbalta cymbalta prednisone viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra prednisone viagra viagra viagra viagra cymbalta viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra keflex cymbalta prednisone keflex viagra viagra keflex viagra cymbalta cymbalta prednisone viagra prednisone prednisone viagra prednisone keflex viagra prednisone prednisone cymbalta prednisone viagra cymbalta prednisone cymbalta levitra prednisone levitra viagra levitra prednisone viagra prednisone prednisone prednisone cymbalta cymbalta viagra prednisone viagra cymbalta cymbalta viagra cymbalta prednisone cymbalta levitra prednisone prednisone prednisone keflex viagra levitra prednisone cymbalta cymbalta levitra viagra viagra keflex viagra cymbalta cymbalta viagra viagra viagra viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra viagra cymbalta prednisone prednisone levitra prednisone viagra prednisone levitra viagra levitra viagra keflex keflex cymbalta cymbalta viagra viagra cymbalta prednisone prednisone viagra cymbalta viagra cymbalta viagra viagra viagra viagra viagra keflex prednisone viagra prednisone viagra cymbalta keflex prednisone cymbalta viagra viagra viagra prednisone keflex viagra viagra levitra viagra viagra prednisone viagra prednisone viagra prednisone prednisone prednisone cymbalta prednisone viagra keflex cymbalta cymbalta viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra viagra viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra viagra viagra prednisone viagra keflex prednisone prednisone levitra keflex viagra viagra prednisone viagra prednisone cymbalta prednisone prednisone viagra prednisone cymbalta viagra

order viagra azithromycin medscape is lexapro a controlled substance what is acyclovir side effects of acyclovir cipro side effects in elderly viagra vs cialis vs levitra generic cialis at walmart how does acyclovir work generic levitra how does cialis work what works better than viagra buy cialis viagra pillen kruidvat cialis discount azithromycine acyclovir 800 mg best price viagra lexapro for anxiety ciprofloxacin hcl finasteride side effects levitra dosage finasteride 5mg side effects viagra effects azithromycin 250 what is tamoxifen viagra costs cialis 5mg daily how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals vardenafil 20mg lexapro and weight loss finasteride hair loss ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects viagra soft pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer how much does cialis cost viagra for sale uk viagra coupon buying viagra cialis tadalafil cialis or viagra azithromycin cost online cialis where to buy viagra finasteride permanent side effects escitalopram nebenwirkungen azithromycin for strep throat cialis dosage strengths propecia tamoxifen and bone pain viagra canada what does azithromycin treat side effects of finasteride 5mg finasteride tamoxifen cost azithromycin 250 mg treatment levitra coupons what does ciprofloxacin treat viagra tablet side effects of tamoxifen viagra pills cialas lexapro 10mg viagra samples azithromycin uses cialis testimonials finasteride side effects in men cialis cheap is azithromycin penicillin what does viagra do cialis price levitra 20 mg von bayer cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis 20mg directions pfizer viagra zithromax what is azithromycin used for tamoxifen and foods to avoid viagra coupons ciprofloxacin eye drops azithromycin for uti price cialis viagra 100 mg azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription levitra 20 mg cost walmart cialis coupons from manufacturer cipro drug class levitra vs viagra for hardness cipro dosage cialis canadian pharmacy cialis 10 mg what is tamoxifen used for cealis side effects of ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects viagra on line acyclovir 800 mg for shingles levitra 20mg finasteride for women cost of viagra azithromycin 250mg ciprofloxacin dose viagra generic viagra substitute azithromycin class ciprofloxacin side effects cialis alternative viagra kaufen generic cialis acyclovir side effects azithromycin coverage acyclovir 400mg acyclovir for shingles viagra single packs finasteride 5 mg viagra prices generic for lexapro tamoxifen nebenwirkungen levitra rezeptfrei deutschland azithromycin pregnancy escitalopram oxalate cialis from canada cialis 5mg side effects of lexapro in women discount cialis how long does viagra last lexapro reviews lexapro para que sirve escitalopram 10mg acyclovir 800mg ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection azithromycin pediatric dosing viagra for men cialis pills for sale canada cialis viagra generico cialis coupon 20 mg generic levitra vardenafil 20mg generic for cialis lexapro vs wellbutrin finasteride results daily cialis acyclovir 200mg cialis 20 mg tamoxifen zithromax antibiotic what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill liquid cialis viagra from canada cialis reviews tamoxifen and weight gain levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix lexapro side effects cialis on line viagra wikipedia lexapro dosing escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve lexapro weight gain levitra 20 mg cialis patent expiration lexapro benefits for women finasteride reviews ciprofloxacin bnf lexapro 5mg viamedic cialis zovirax ointment viagra 50mg levitra coupon viagra 100mg finasteride and enlarged prostate cialis voucher how long for lexapro to work what infections does ciprofloxacin treat side effects of cialis canada viagra cialis canada lexapro and weight gain azithromycin tablets over the counter viagra what is cialis azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cialis samples overnight acyclovir medication finasteride 5 mg tab levitra online azithromycin pregnancy category female viagra azithromycin and alcohol cialis 30 day trial coupon buy generic levitra acyclovir 400 mg finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic finasteride effets secondaires cialis patent expiration 2017 acyclovir ointment 5 propecia side effects zovirax pills cialis for women azithromycin drug class cialis for bph post finasteride syndrome escitalopram acyclovir ointment acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day lowest cialis prices lexapro side effects in women ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic ciprofloxacin used for azithromycin z pak azithromycin 250 mg sophia viagra cialis coupons 2017 cipro dangers cipro for uti canadian viagra utilisation viagra viagra nebenwirkungen levitra vs viagra what is lexapro used for ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin dosage viagra 100 tamoxifen bijwerkingen natural viagra viagra activate levitra prices cialis generic tadalafil cialis savings card ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 generic lexapro vardenafil vs viagra cialis 30 day sample finasteride dosage ciprofloxacin 250mg acyclovir cream lexapro medication lexapro and weight gain in women finasteride efectos secundarios erectile dysfunction cialis azithromycin side effects levitra 10 mg prezzo celexa vs lexapro escitalopram 20 mg cyalis what is cipro used for generic viagra 100mg finasteride 5mg what is lexapro cipro side effects azithromycin 5 day dose pack levitra without a doctor prescription how long for azithromycin to take effect free viagra azithromycin 500 what is viagra azithromycin 500 mg cheap viagra zoloft vs lexapro cialis vs viagra equipe argentine viagra viagra price what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat zovirax cream cipro uses what is lexapro for cialis for men how to take cialis tamoxifen therapy lexapro bula viagra for women levitra vs viagra cipro antibiotic cheap cialis sex viagra for women generic cialis tadalafil lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy cialis dosage recommendations cialis patent expiration date extended acyclovir for cold sores finasteride 1mg lexapro withdrawal cialis dosage levitra prezzo in farmacia zithromax z-pak tamoxifen side effects azithromycine 250 mg side effects of azithromycin lexapro vs celexa ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution what is acyclovir used for finasteride 5mg tab escitalopram effets secondaires what is escitalopram ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten tamoxifen lawsuits lexapro side effects in men lexapro 10 mg viagra medicine side effects of lexapro 10 mg viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland cialis generic cipro and tendonitis 9 levitra at walmart azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack cheap levitra lexapro manufacturer website viagra uk buy viagra acyclovir dosing wholesale cialis ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen azithromycin liquid viagra on line no prec cialis coupons printable viagra wiki cialis cost what does finasteride do canadian cialis acyclovir vs valacyclovir thuoc azithromycin lexapro coupons viagra 100mg tablets retail price ciprofloxacin uses levitra erfahrungen cialis prices discount viagra buy levitra online cialis for sale cialis free trial ciprofloxacin spc free cialis lexapro dosage nolvadex lexapro dosages viagra vs cialis vs levitra is azithromycin what is ciprofloxacin lexapro overdose viagra cost cialis 20mg acyclovir dosage ciprofloxacin drops ciprofloxacin dosierung viagra pill cialis medication ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets finasteride medication azithromycin for pneumonia cilias lexapro 20mg how does lexapro work what is azithromycin for herbal viagra lexapro generic name viagra sex cialis tamoxifen side effects in women viagra for sale ciprofloxacin 500 mg what is azithromycin wellbutrin and lexapro cialis generic availability cialis coupons finasteride vs dutasteride finasteride tablets is tamoxifen chemotherapy azithromycin three times a week viagra without a doctor prescription effects of stopping finasteride when will cialis go generic viagra alternatives zovirax for cold sores cialis professional first few days on lexapro viagra receptfritt cipro 500 how to wean off lexapro zovirax dosage cialis pricing withdrawal from lexapro azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter levitra does lexapro cause weight gain side effects of azithromycin 250 mg cialis otc lexapro generic azithromycin vs erythromycin what is ciprofloxacin used for levitra 20 mg precio farmacia stopping lexapro acyclovir side effects of finasteride cialis pharmacy prices ciprofloxacin side effects in women ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab finasteride for hair loss what is cipro usually prescribed for viagra bestellen antibiotic ciprofloxacin buy cialis online azithromycin tablet viagra cialis levitra generic what is cipro cost of cialis azithromycin eye drops escitalopram 10 mg ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg zithromax dosage buy viagra online viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung lexapro vs zoloft acyclovir dosage for cold sores zithromax 500 mg cialis sample zovirax cialis coupon print viagra tesco cialis vs viagra cialis coupon side effects lexapro lexapro withdrawal symptoms ciprofloxacin for dogs viagra natural viagra viagra side effects viagra tablets buy generic viagra how to use viagra cialis side effects viagra vs cialis azithromycin cialis effects finasteride long term effects cialis website online viagra what is finasteride weaning off lexapro tamoxifen interaction tamoxifen citrate ciprofloxacin 500 azithromycin dosage cialis 5 mg effects of stopping lexapro suddenly side effects of lexapro ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics viagra vs cialis revatio vs viagra cialis for daily use side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg tamoxifen langzeitfolgen escitalopram side effects cialis online viagra without a doctor prescription usa viagra online cialis pills ciprofloxacin hydrochloride lexapro what is finasteride used for what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for acyclovir dose is ciprofloxacin a penicillin ciprofloxacin coverage cialis daily buy levitra viagra sans ordonnance what is acyclovir for lexapro side effects men ciprofloxacin drug class cialis samples viagra dosage cialis copay card cialis trial common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg cipro antibiotics generic viagra azithromycin 500mg ciprofloxacin 500mg women viagra cipro levitra 20mg cost per pill how does viagra work ciprofloxacin 250 mg ciprofloxacin class how to get off lexapro side effects of viagra viagra alternative tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 viagra en ligne livraison 24h 200 cialis coupon

You Might Also Enjoy:

If you found the information provided on this webpage to be helpful, please click my Plus+1 button so that others may also find it.