Contact Us
    CONTACT US

    Please use the contact form to send us an email - and receive a response within 12 hours.

    Emergency? Call 720-220-2277 (24/7)







    Please leave this field empty.

Map To Our Office
Read Out Blog
Case Evaluation
Charged With A Crime?

Mar 22

Does A Colorado Criminal Defendant Have A Right To Search The Alleged Victim’s Home For Evidence Of Innocence?

By H. Michael Steinberg – Colorado Sex Crimes Criminal Defense Lawyer – Attorney

Does A Colorado Criminal Defendant Have A Right To Search The Alleged Victim’s Home For Evidence Of Innocence? In 2015 the Colorado Court of Appeals answered this question – yes but it’s “complicated.”

In the case of People in the Interest of E.G., 2015COA18 (decided February 26, 2015), a juvenile charged with a sex crime demanded to search the so called “scene of the crime” – that is his grandmother’s home where the alleged sex assaults took place.

The trial judge ruled – as most judge’s believe – that he could not order – had no authority to order – a “non-party” (a private person uncharged to the case) – to make her home available to the Defendant’s team.

The Ruling – Defendant’s Can Search Alleged Crime Scenes – Sometimes

“[A] trial court has the authority to allow discovery of a crime scene to the defense, even if the discovery implicates constitutionally-protected privacy rights of a non-party, provided that the defendant’s justification for the information, which derives from his constitutional rights to due process and to present a defense, outweighs the privacy interests.”

But in this case the Defendant could not meet the necessary standard to support the search. The question then arises – what kind of showing is needed before a judge can order the search of a third party’s home?

What Is Necessary To Gain Access To A Private “Scene Of The Crime?”

The form of the request takes the form of a motion requesting court-ordered access to the crime scene. This is a form of “discovery” in a criminal case. Since a defendant has a constitutional right to present evidence on his behalf and to confront adverse witnesses the right of a Defendant to compel material evidence from private third parties, does exist – but it – as noted above – is subject to certain limitations.

Colorado Court’s HAVE Allowed Defense Teams To Cross Into The Due Process Rights of Non-Party – Private Persons In The Past

So called “intrusions” into the rights of private persons by the criminally accused has been permitted in other kinds of cases and under different factual circumstances:

Some Examples Include:

A Court can order a victim in a sexual assault case to undergo an involuntary psychological or physical examination, (provided that the defendant’s need to discover the information outweighs the victim’s privacy interests.)

A child’s confidential educational records can be “discovered” by the defense with an adequate showing of the defendant’s need for the evidence.

Pretrial discovery subpoenas can be issued – even for privileged, confidential, or otherwise private materials in the hands of third parties – provided that there is a balancing of interests and the defendant makes a sufficient showing of need for the disclosure of material information.

The disclosure of third-party blood donors’ records can be disclosed in a limited discovery procedure that discloses the records but also protects donors’ privacy.

Records Can Be Subpoenaed – But Real Estate – Such As Crime Scenes Are Not Mobile

The Court cannot practically order a private person to bring their home or business into the courtroom. Therefore p this case breaks new ground in setting up the kind of evidentiary showing needed to gain access to a private person’s property.

A Defendant’s right to inspect an alleged crime scene does in fact implicate concepts of fundamental fairness and due process.

Why Is This An Important Case For The Defense Of A Colorado Case – Such As A Sex Crime Charge?

The reason this is such an important case and has made national headlines – is that Colorado now joins a minority of states that permit Defendant initiated searches of private property more tips here. This kind of search can yield massive benefits to the defense of a Colorado criminal case – (see below). But first you have to hurdle some red tape..

We therefore hold that a trial court may authorize access to a crime scene to the defense, even if such access implicates constitutionally-protected privacy rights of a non-party, provided that the defendant’s justification for the information outweighs any privacy interests.

1. The test is this – “to obtain access, the defendant must demonstrate that the evidence desired is relevant, material, and necessary to the defense. The Trial Court then balances the Defendant’s proffered justification as against the rights and legitimate interests of the non-party person.”

2. The showing must establish that the search “would yield relevant material evidence, not already provided, necessary for the preparation of the defense case.”

3. The Motion cannot “have the objective of causing intimidation, harassment, or abuse.”

4. The Defendant must show a “compelling need” test to a Defendant’s discovery request.

The Motion To Search Or To Otherwise Access Another’s Private Property Must Be SPECIFIC

In the In Re: E.G. case – the Defendant failed to meet the standards necessary. His defense lawyer failed to demonstrate that the inspection of the crime scene would yield relevant material evidence necessary to present his defense nd to demonstrate specifically how accessing the crime scene would produce material and relevant evidence not otherwise provided to him from another source.

The Motion was general – provided no specific evidentiary purpose for which he needed this evidence to present his defense at trial. And “failed to elaborate as to why viewing, photographing, or sensing the crime scene was essential to the defense trial strategy.”

The Motion To Search The Crime Scene Must:

  1. Articulate a specific need for the information requested to outweigh privacy interests.
  2. Must not be too general and speculative and there must be some showing that the requested intrusion is relevant and material to the defense to demonstrate his need for access to a crime scene controlled by a private third party.

How Would Such A Search Be Accomplished Procedurally?- The Colorado Court Of Appeals Defers This Question

Because the Trial Court denied the Motion and the Court of Appeals found the Motion lacking in specificity and therefore no search was permitted… issues as to the procedure to be followed to give the private person the right to notice and the opportunity to be heard regarding access to the crime scene by the defense is not addressed in the decision.

There was an indication by the Court that the procedure to be followed would be similar to the issue in other kinds of cases – involving the issuance of third party subpoenas to produce evidence, a request to inspect, a hearing and then a Court Orfder granting access to the property.

Last Issue – What Evidence Could You Search For – How Might That Evidence Help The Defense Case?

The types of evidence in a criminal trial that can be developed at the crime scene – evidence that was missed by the police during their search – is endless.

Evidence in this context can consist of:

    • Computer or Digital Evidence
    • Documentary Evidence – (Writings such as diaries, journals, letters and even e-mails).
    • Every Type of Physical Evidence (can be used to “rule out” the Defendant and include other suspects).
    • Fingerprints
    • Blood DNA
    • Blood Splatters Evidence
    • Hair Strand (for possible DNA testing – hair follicle must be intact). -Color of a hair strand to rule out the Defendant.
    • Skin (DNA)
    • Semen (In Rape cases)
    • Shoe Prints
    • Photographs of the Scene
    • Ballistics ( casings, gun powder, bullets)

Does A Colorado Criminal Defendant Have A Right To Search The Alleged Victim’s Home For Evidence Of Innocence?

If you found any information I have provided on this web page article helpful please click my Plus+1 or the Share button below so that others may also find it.

Never stop fighting – never stop believing in yourself and your right to due process of law.

 ABOUT THE AUTHOR: H. Michael Steinberg – Email The Author at  hmsteinberg@hotmail.com – A Denver Colorado Criminal Defense Lawyer – or call his office at 303-627-7777 during business hours – or call his cell if you cannot wait and need his immediate assistance – 720-220-2277. Attorney H. Michael Steinberg is passionate about criminal defense. His extensive knowledge and experience of Colorado Criminal Law gives him the edge you need to properly handle your case.

You must make a responsible choice for a Colorado Criminal Defense Lawyer – we encourage you to look at our firm. Over the last 30 plus years – H. Michael has mastered nearly every area of criminal law, procedure and trial and courtroom practice and he is passionate about getting you the best result in your case. He has written, and continues to write, extensively on Colorado criminal law and he hopes this article – – helps you in some small way. He hopes this article makes your case more understandable to you as regards the topic of this article:- Does A Colorado Criminal Defendant Have A Right To Search The Alleged Victim’s Home For Evidence Of Innocence?

what is acyclovir viagra 100 levitra generic cipro uses ciprofloxacin dosierung escitalopram 10 mg levitra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra pills levitra online cialis tadalafil ciprofloxacin drug class cialis otc lexapro side effects in men viagra natural canadian cialis acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day sex viagra for women finasteride ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics cialis generic tadalafil side effects of lexapro viagra from canada generic cialis tadalafil cialis for sale cialis patent expiration 2017 viagra tablets levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix ciprofloxacin dose ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection how to take cialis cialis dosage recommendations tamoxifen bijwerkingen liquid cialis viagra canada escitalopram 20 mg cipro 500 lexapro withdrawal symptoms nolvadex how long does viagra last cialis samples overnight azithromycin pregnancy acyclovir medication cipro and tendonitis cialis for bph levitra vs viagra ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution cialis price ciprofloxacin drops free cialis buy viagra online utilisation viagra cheap viagra effects of stopping lexapro suddenly cialis coupons printable cialis medication is tamoxifen chemotherapy effects of stopping finasteride where to buy viagra viagra generic zovirax pills what is tamoxifen used for cialis 30 day trial coupon cilias discount viagra cialis coupon print acyclovir for cold sores equipe argentine viagra azithromycin liquid side effects of viagra azithromycin for pneumonia revatio vs viagra cialis testimonials ciprofloxacin used for azithromycin 500 mg viagra 100mg tablets retail price viagra for sale lexapro and weight gain ciprofloxacin 500mg buy levitra online viagra for sale uk what works better than viagra cialis daily zithromax z-pak viagra single packs what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill viagra bestellen viagra receptfritt finasteride and enlarged prostate acyclovir 400mg tamoxifen cialis alternative cialis 20mg directions zithromax dosage lexapro vs celexa lexapro dosages azithromycine 250 mg viagra soft acyclovir cream what is cipro used for thuoc azithromycin buy generic viagra buying viagra what is cipro cialis 20mg common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg finasteride side effects azithromycin vs erythromycin side effects of azithromycin buy cialis viagra sans ordonnance buy viagra cialis 30 day sample what is lexapro generic cialis at walmart celexa vs lexapro ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects ciprofloxacin side effects in women cipro antibiotic viagra en ligne livraison 24h ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten how does lexapro work viagra vs cialis vs levitra cialis coupon lexapro generic viagra dosage finasteride 5 mg escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve lexapro 5mg lexapro and weight loss acyclovir dosing 200 cialis coupon side effects of lexapro 10 mg cialis coupons cialis prices azithromycin uses finasteride reviews how to wean off lexapro acyclovir ointment azithromycin escitalopram 10mg what is azithromycin for acyclovir dose ciprofloxacin dosage zovirax dosage azithromycin three times a week lexapro 10 mg side effects lexapro levitra 10 mg prezzo lexapro 10mg cipro dosage buy cialis online cialis sample price cialis what is acyclovir for how to use viagra tamoxifen side effects lexapro lexapro side effects ciprofloxacin hcl cialis cheap lexapro dosing tamoxifen and foods to avoid how long for lexapro to work lexapro benefits for women ciprofloxacin for dogs acyclovir for shingles is azithromycin penicillin cealis generic levitra how long for azithromycin to take effect escitalopram nebenwirkungen finasteride efectos secundarios azithromycin tablet what infections does ciprofloxacin treat stopping lexapro cialis voucher cialis effects women viagra generic cialis cialis professional cialis free trial cialis canadian pharmacy acyclovir 9 levitra at walmart azithromycin 250mg finasteride effets secondaires ciprofloxacin class cipro dangers what is acyclovir used for cialis samples levitra 20 mg cost walmart levitra 20mg viagra costs viagra activate lexapro for anxiety cialis website cialis generic viagra pillen kruidvat levitra coupons cialis dosage strengths lexapro manufacturer website cipro ciprofloxacin 250 mg vardenafil 20mg viagra price tamoxifen cost finasteride 5mg tab side effects of finasteride 5mg lexapro vs wellbutrin propecia what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for ciprofloxacin coverage cialis vs viagra escitalopram oxalate ciprofloxacin azithromycin pregnancy category finasteride hair loss cialis vs viagra zovirax for cold sores escitalopram azithromycin class viagra vs cialis vs levitra zovirax generic lexapro canadian viagra escitalopram effets secondaires online cialis side effects of acyclovir cyalis cialis pills for sale tamoxifen nebenwirkungen what is azithromycin cost of cialis viagra nebenwirkungen azithromycin 250 azithromycin side effects cialis discount tamoxifen and bone pain cipro side effects viagra tesco cialis generic for lexapro cost of viagra how does acyclovir work finasteride 5mg side effects erectile dysfunction cialis viagra cialis azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter tamoxifen therapy online viagra azithromycin tablets what does finasteride do what is cialis what is cipro usually prescribed for tamoxifen lawsuits cialis canada acyclovir dosage for cold sores ciprofloxacin spc what does viagra do what is lexapro used for acyclovir 800mg generic viagra what is viagra ciprofloxacin side effects zithromax zoloft vs lexapro cialis pricing cialis cost side effects of cialis cialis trial finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic viagra tablet azithromycin for strep throat ciprofloxacin 500 lexapro overdose when will cialis go generic viagra kaufen cialas azithromycin coverage cialis dosage azithromycine cialis coupon 20 mg what is finasteride used for viagra wikipedia lexapro and weight gain in women azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription is lexapro a controlled substance acyclovir vs valacyclovir acyclovir dosage levitra lexapro generic name finasteride medication pfizer viagra cialis pills viagra medicine natural viagra azithromycin cost cialis 5mg daily how does viagra work levitra 20mg cost per pill finasteride 1mg is azithromycin viagra samples finasteride for women weaning off lexapro what is finasteride wholesale cialis viagra prices cialis on line finasteride permanent side effects levitra prices levitra 20 mg precio farmacia levitra dosage tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 lexapro side effects men cialis pharmacy prices ciprofloxacin 250mg levitra erfahrungen what is tamoxifen zithromax antibiotic tamoxifen side effects in women finasteride results levitra vs viagra for hardness ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab levitra prezzo in farmacia viagra online discount cialis cialis coupons from manufacturer generic for cialis viagra on line no prec ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg lexapro side effects in women cialis for daily use best price viagra tamoxifen citrate lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals viagra ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic ciprofloxacin bnf viagra sex lexapro bula cialis 20 mg finasteride side effects in men cipro antibiotics viagra for women side effects of ciprofloxacin azithromycin for uti ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 first few days on lexapro ciprofloxacin 500 mg cialis patent expiration cialis patent expiration date extended side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg tamoxifen interaction canada cialis buy levitra viagra 50mg azithromycin and alcohol levitra 20 mg herbal viagra pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer azithromycin eye drops generic viagra 100mg viagra alternative cialis coupons 2017 cipro drug class viagra coupon finasteride 5 mg tab azithromycin medscape azithromycin drug class ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets finasteride dosage what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat azithromycin 500 erfahrungen lexapro coupons azithromycin 250 mg what does azithromycin treat is ciprofloxacin a penicillin cialis or viagra how does cialis work finasteride for hair loss how much does cialis cost wellbutrin and lexapro daily cialis levitra vs viagra acyclovir 800 mg for shingles cialis copay card zovirax cream cialis side effects cialis for men side effects of azithromycin 250 mg viagra generico viagra side effects viagra without a doctor prescription usa azithromycin 500mg lexapro dosage cipro for uti acyclovir 200mg side effects of finasteride ciprofloxacin uses lexapro 20mg viagra coupons azithromycin 500 azithromycin 5 day dose pack ciprofloxacin hydrochloride levitra 20 mg von bayer azithromycin pediatric dosing cialis without a doctor’s prescription viagra for men viagra alternatives finasteride long term effects does lexapro cause weight gain viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland free viagra what is ciprofloxacin used for over the counter viagra azithromycin dosage levitra without a doctor prescription viamedic cialis how to get off lexapro what is azithromycin used for order viagra withdrawal from lexapro levitra coupon cialis from canada viagra without a doctor prescription tamoxifen and weight gain viagra 100mg canada viagra lexapro medication ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen azithromycin 250 mg treatment side effects of tamoxifen cialis savings card escitalopram side effects what does ciprofloxacin treat viagra vs cialis lexapro para que sirve lexapro vs zoloft zovirax ointment tamoxifen langzeitfolgen cialis reviews sophia viagra cialis generic availability viagra wiki viagra substitute post finasteride syndrome acyclovir side effects viagra cost ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects acyclovir 800 mg viagra uk what is ciprofloxacin acyclovir ointment 5 viagra on line female viagra lexapro withdrawal finasteride vs dutasteride azithromycin z pak lexapro weight gain what is escitalopram cialis 5mg viagra 100 mg cialis online side effects of lexapro in women cipro side effects in elderly buy generic levitra generic levitra vardenafil 20mg lexapro reviews azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack cialis for women propecia side effects antibiotic ciprofloxacin what is lexapro for cheap levitra vardenafil vs viagra viagra vs cialis cialis 5 mg finasteride tablets acyclovir 400 mg cialis 10 mg viagra effects cheap cialis finasteride 5mg lowest cialis prices zithromax 500 mg viagra pill ciprofloxacin eye drops viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung

Summary
Article Name
Does A Colorado Criminal Defendant Have A Right To Search The Alleged Victim’s Home For Evidence Of Innocence?
Description
Does A Colorado Criminal Defendant Have A Right To Search The Alleged Victim’s Home For Evidence Of Innocence? In 2015 the Colorado Court of Appeals answered this question - yes but it’s "complicated."
Author

You Might Also Enjoy:

If you found the information provided on this webpage to be helpful, please click my Plus+1 button so that others may also find it.